Apr 26 2007
American Idol gives back…
I was reading eric keck’s excellent post about last night’s charity fundraiser sponsored by American Idol. He writes:
doing the stuff… without any explaination… other than the obvious social justice… (which was implicit and not delved into… but rightly so… a talent search show isn’t necessarily the platform or the motive.)
$30,000,000 for the poor… amazing in ONE night. i was saddened to watch as i realized that money is a beautiful band-aid
I confess. I am an American Idol fan. I really liked Carrie Underwood, and I thought Taylor Hicks was the right choice last year. And yes, I like Reuben, Fantasia, Clay and Kelly Clarkson.
It just felt odd to hear Ryan Seacrest and Simon Cowell walking and talking in what I am sure were well-scripted scense through the poverty-stricken conditions in Africa, expressing compassion and really, abhorrence of what they were seeing. And then the videos of poverty-stricken American kids that are going to be helped by the money raised.
Here is what I was thinking: Where is the Church of Jesus Christ? I was wondering what would happen if we spent half as much on marketing, the production of weekend services and facilities and took the surplus money and poured it into attacking the roots of spiritual darkness at the tactical level. Attacking poverty with education and compassion and job training and financial initiatives. Attacking homelessness with clinics and housing and relationship. Attacking hunger and thirst with food and drink. Attacking violence with love. And fatherlessness with the love of the Heavenly Father. Maybe then we wouldn’t celebrate our efforts with a song that proclaims the absence of God and religion and we could imagine just a little bit what the kingdom of God might be like.
Ah well, I am pretty sure that wouldn’t meet my needs. I wonder if the worship leader is going to do my favorite songs this weekend.
3 Responses to “American Idol gives back…”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Great point! I wonder if Christ ask the same question?
It struck me as a pompous bit of self-promotion for a franchise that has returned a fraction of what it has taken in - or nothing, if you ask me.
What they gave back isn’t even a third of their ad revenue from one show. Meanwhile, they are in their sixth season of stealing money from viewers, phone voters, advertisers and the general public.
And, what a shocker … no one was eliminated, which means that all the votes were for naught, since they get to milk this nonsense for another week of prime-time advertising revenue.
I see your point Anthony. Simon looked pretty uncomfortable in the video from Africa. Still, networks are not known for their “tithing” or for their generosity.
Of course, they are going to do well! My actual point was that it wouldn’t hurt if those of us who are professed Christ-followers were a little better know for your generosity, kindness and charitable acts.